Fastener Selection, Development and Validation

by admin on April 8, 2010

In the development of many products, fastener selection is often neglected until the design is being finalized. In applications where fasteners are required, they should be among the first parts to be considered.

One of the first questions to ask is does the fastener have to carry load or is it only there to hold the part in a specific location? Either answer will raise another set of questions: What is the applied load? What materials are being clamped together? What are the environmental conditions? Depending on the application, other questions may need to be answered. Every answer is important, because if these issues aren’t addressed, the fasteners chosen could be inappropriate for the design.

During the development stage of the design, the selected fasteners should be tested for the appropriate torque and clamp load, using the parts that will clamped together. This will ensure that the torque specification developed for the manufacturing/assembly plant will work with the production parts. During the validation stage, when the design goes into final testing, the fasteners should be tightened to the specification and indexed for monitoring during duty-cycle testing.
Fasteners must be considered throughout the product development cycle. They should be part of the equation when developing the functional objectives for the product, as well as during design and development and validation testing. Obviously, fastener choice is key to efficient manufacturing and product assembly. Finally, fasteners are a vital concern in determining the aftermarket serviceability of a product.

Most fastener-related recalls are in the automotive industry, per the editor of the American Fastener Journal (12/2009). However, other products have had recalls due to fastener problems. One example is the recent recall of the Evenflo Envision High Chairs (April, 2009).

There is a great opportunity to significantly reduce the number of product recalls due to fastener problems if proper care is taken in fastener selection, development, and validation.

{ 3 comments… read them below or add one }

1 John O'Toole April 29, 2010 at 10:53 pm

Jeff, After reading the fastener article it reminded me that one the suppliers we are developing could really use some help with torque specification development, tools and processes for a one of a kind fuel blower. I will provide contact info under separate cover. Best Regards, John

Reply

2 Eric McCarty May 14, 2010 at 8:40 pm

Nice article. I would add that the fastener material, process and performance expectations should be clearly stated, which is typically communicated in the form of customer or industry standards. Of particular concern to fasteners are corrosion requirements, not only of the fastener and fastener coating but of the joint. Electrical grounding, dissimilar metal galvanic corrosion, hydrogen embrittlement, stress corrosion cracking, etc. are all fastener related issues that if not properly tested and validated may result in fastener joint failures that are discovered at the worst possible time, when in service and by the customer.

Reply

3 James Kuiken June 27, 2010 at 7:35 pm

It’s truly amazing how many people know so little about fastener design, specifications etc… One of the best things that happened to me early in my career was being responsible for a large amount of bolted joints on a vehicle platform. Still today, many years later I fall back on lessons I learned in my first few months on the job about selecting the correct fastener for the application, testing appropriately and knowing what the data is telling you.

Reply

Leave a Comment

*

Previous post:

Next post: